Directors Not Criminally Liable For Company's Contractual Breach Without Proof Of Fraud: Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court has said that a company's inability to pay its dues because of financial distress is a civil issue, not a criminal offense. A director cannot be prosecuted for cheating unless there is clear proof of personal fraud or personal gain. Justice Neena Bansal Krishna quashed cheating charges against a former managing director of Creative Wares Limited, a manufacturing company that later ran into financial trouble and was declared a sick industrial company by the BIFR. The court...

Only Final SFIO Report, Not Interim Report, Can Trigger Prosecution Under Companies Act: Calcutta High Court

The Calcutta High Court has clarified that the central government cannot initiate prosecution under the Companies Act on the basis of an interim report submitted by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office and must wait for the final investigation report after completion of the probe. Justice Krishna Rao made the observation while allowing a writ petition filed by Sunil Kumar Agarwal and quashing a Look Out Circular issued against him during the pendency of an SFIO investigation, noting that...

Special Court Cannot Hear Private Complaints In Companies Act Fraud Cases; Only SFIO Can File: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court on Friday held that a special court cannot entertain a private complaint in cases involving fraud under the Companies Act. It ruled that where an offence attracts punishment under the fraud provision, cognisance can be taken only on a complaint filed by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office or an authorised officer of the Central government. A Division Bench of Justice J K Maheshwari and Justice K Vinod Chandran held that offences under Section 448 of the Companies Act, which...